Take your Nuance elsewhere
I've seen one too many attempts to argue for "nuance" when it comes to using AI to make a videogame, and even worse too many of these attempts invoked the specter of Marxism to support their position.
As someone who both considers themselves to be a Communist, and who considers AI and its proliferation to be a fascist power grab, I refuse to cede ground to these people.
So in order to put things right, I present to you:
The three ways how Brendan Keogh and his particular flavour of Marxist reading is wrong about AI:
(1)The shape of AI-Tools in an imagined communist future is irrelevant to the present day
Brendan Keogh's essay in general falls into a type of Marxist writing that I personally don't like, in that it gives me the impression that it mostly uses quotes from other texts as an intellectual cudgel and not really as a way to support its own position.
There are two fairly lengthy quotes that I personally found to be irrelevant to the problem at hand, but that do serve as a way to position the Essay itself as a "serious and scientific" perspective on its subject matter, as opposed to a personal opinion.
However, after establishing itself as being all about Science and not the imagination, it immediately proceeds to imagine various speculative futures where Communism has happened and AI is still around and actually good.
The great thing about human beings is that everything is possible within our imagination, but it's also not real.
I watch motorsports, which is fueled by money laundering and reactionary car propaganda. I could run around and tell people "yeah, but imagine if it was *good*!", but that would be oblivious of the fact that its current structure and purpose are the exact opposite. It also wouldn't offer any perspective on how to get there. In fact, in its ignorance it would be more similar to Propaganda than anything else.
As powerful a tool your imagination can be to give yourself the motivation to fight for a world that isn't what we have right now, it's important to understand that whatever world this is going to be, has to grow out of the world as it is right now.
(2) A Teleological perspective about history and technological progress
The usage of imagined futures makes sense, considering that the piece itself has a rather naive view of Technology and History. For example, he claims that the Smartphone (which he describes as an objectively 'good' thing to have happened, which too is debatable) was invented by Human Beings, and not by Capitalism. While it is true that Humans have invented the Smartphone, it is also worth mentioning that it was Humans who are living under Capitalism that have invented the Smartphone and that the specific shape and definition of it is one that can only exist because of Capitalism.
His perspective on History and technological progress seems very teleological to me, which puts him in line with early Marxist writing I've encountered.
I don't know if this was just due to some kind of inherent optimism, or a more fundamental believe, but there is a certain sense of inevitability about Communism in how some particularly early Marxists talk about it. It's this very strange mixture where on the one hand you have the argument that history moves in accordance to and reflects the material conditions under which people exist under. At the same time, Communism is framed as the inevitable outcome of the current contradictions under which we exist, and that it both needs to be brought into being, but will also bring itself into being when the time is right.
It is Teleological in nature in that it describes history as process that moves towards a specific final stage, or purpose.
I first encountered this type of approach when I studied Evolutionary Theory, specifically Human Evolution. Everyone kind of knows this image of the "March of Progress" right? It displays human natural history as a sort of inevitable linear process from some kind of quadrupedal primate, to a Chimpanzee and ending with the Modern Human. It suggests that the purpose of Evolution was to bring Humans into the world, when it actually is a mostly directionless process where organisms change over time in reaction to both external and internal factors. It just so happened that somehow we came into the world. It appears linear and purposeful, when we look back at it, but that doesn't mean that this was its purpose.
As much as History didn't end with early 90s liberalism, it also won't end with Communism. Only the demise of Human beings will end it, or at least our involvement.
Anyway, the reason I wanted to mention this, is because I think Brendan Keogh's position on technology, as something that just happens by accident and has no real connection to capitalism itself, is tied to this very teleological reading of history.
If everything is always moving towards its conclusion, then obviously any technology that comes into being was meant to be.
I do not think that this a particularly good way of looking at both History and Technology, because it kind of makes you apathetic towards it all.
If Human history moves in concert and in response to the material conditions under which it exists, then this means that anything that comes out of that process too is in response to those conditions around it.
In that sense, while it is surely possible that humans would have invented the Smartphone under Communism, the fact is that it was invented under Capitalism and thus carries Capitalism within it. The same goes for Large Language Models and the Tools that are powered by them.
So when we're debating the purpose and usefulness of technology, it is important to understand the conditions under which they came into being, and the purpose they are supposed to fulfill.
In the case of AI, it is important to understand who is in control of the data that is being used to power them and what these people are trying to accomplish.
AI is a fascist project and an attempt to take human culture out of the hands of the people and transfer it into the hands of a small group of very rich human beings. It is destructive, both on an environmental level, but also in how it destroys trust, solidarity and collaboration between us, and instead replaces it with a sycophantic middle-man.
It is also based on and fueled by labour exploitation.
(3) Using AI to make a videogame has nothing to do with Consumption
Most attempts to argue for a more "nuanced" approach to AI usage within videogame production from a sort-of left-leaning perspective have attempted to frame AI-usage as a problem of Consumption. Since all Goods under Capitalism are somehow the result of, or touched by exploitative Labour conditions, it is no use to argue for more ethical consumption habits, therefore shaming Game Developers who use AI for their games is an equally pointless endeavor.
However, a person who is using AI-Tools to make a videogame is not doing so for the purpose of consumption, they do so for the purpose of production.
Brendan Keogh even mentions it, when he says that both Paolo Pedercini and House House have used an available morally-compromised technology to make their products.*
However, I disagree with his conclusion, that in offering a "thoughtful" perspective on the problems they had to consider, it somehow absolves them of any responsibility.
Let's imagine an absurd scenario where we replace "I/We have used AI" in both disclosures with "I/We have used unpaid and uncredited Labour", would we call for nuance here as well?
Would we get "Marxist" arguments about the value of working for exposure?
As of right now, no one is forced to use AI Tools to make a videogame. In fact, as a producer of goods under Capitalism, you actually have a lot of freedom to decide how to go about your business, since Capitalism broadly speaking only cares about you having the means to do so, not whether or not your approach is in line with its own values.
Neither Paolo Pedercini, nor House House or any other Game Developer out there is under obligations to use AI. They made that decision and regardless of their stated reason, it ultimately comes down to the fact that using a Large Language model was deemed to be the more 'efficient' (=cheaper) approach than whatever alternative they could think of.
They were not exploited workers, they were small business owners doing what small business owners tend to do: Erode Solidarity and Labour protection and thus doing the dirty work for those who already own everything, while complaining about how the world itself is against them.
Arguing for a nuanced stance on AI, from a "Marxist" perspective in my eyes is either misguided, or malicious, because it will not serve the interests of those who are oppressed by Capitalism, it will only serve Capitalism.
Let's end this all with a speculative scenario, like any good and true Marxist would:
Imagine AI tools proliferate further, but Communism doesn't. Imagine it becomes impossible to make any computer program without relying on some kind of AI-chatbot to do the work for you. Imagine you want to make a Game with a political message, maybe about how Capitalism is a death cult, or something like it.
Maybe it's my lack of optimism, but considering the world we live in right now, I find it much more likely that Anthropic at some point is going to tell you that your concept of a Socialist videogame is against its terms of Service, than that we get the magical Communist AI that is good for all.
History doesn't just happen on its own, it has to be brought into being. Whatever better world we imagine has to be build and prepared by us. I have no idea what this looks like, but something tells me that being more open to the fascist chatbots is not the right way to go.
*If anything, the actual hypocrisy within the IGF disclosure process lies in the fact that submissions only need to provide statements in regards to their AI usage and not in regards to their wider Labour conditions. That however doesn't meant that using AI to make a videogames is somehow less disgusting.
Related Posts:
AI being everywhere does not make it okay to use:
https://mokkograd.net/posts/2026-10-22-AI-being-everywhere-does-not-make-it-okay...
The Threat of organic Videogames
https://mokkograd.net/posts/2026-08-19-The-Threat-of-Organic-Videogames
Waste is for the Dead
https://mokkograd.net/posts/2026-02-02-Waste-is-for-the-Dead
The Capitalist State Human Culture and the inevitability of History
https://mokkograd.net/posts/2025-03-30-The-Capitalist-State-Human-Culture-and-th...